To begin, allow me to clarify what is meant when one talks of the "Big Three": There's Standard's and Poor's (S&P), Moody's Investor Services (Moody's), and Fitch Ratings (Fitch). All three agencies are American and their main purpose is to monitor companies, governments, and financial products and to then determine their creditworthiness. This information is in turn used by other governments, investors, and banks to ascertain the riskiness of an investment (say buying government bonds or stock in a certain company, for example). In other words, rating agencies are supposed to do all the hard work when it comes to calculating the likelihood that a government, company, or product will fail to yield the interest rate that they are promising. To make things a bit more uniform, these agencies assign a rating to whatever it is that they are considering.
Ratings differ a bit across the three agencies but for the most part, they are not unlike the typical grading scale used in American elementary and high schools. The more A's or + signs, the higher the likelihood that the investment product will live up to its word. So a government with a AAA rating is a government that will almost certainly (barring a huge unforeseen catastrophe) be able to fulfill its end of the bargain once an investment comes due. A's become B's, B's become C's and finally C's become D's. It's worth mentioning here that investing is all about weighing two different concepts on a scale and then making a decision: how much risk are you willing to take vs. how much return do you want to make. AAA rating investments are usually very safe, but they don't make much money. A CCC rating investment is very very risky, but typically returns will be much higher than those of a AAA rating. So if you're someone who likes risk, you don't aim for AAA ratings but you risk losing money if the entity goes under.
So who cares about what rating agencies have to say (and this is the reason they are so powerful)? The answer is: EVERYONE cares. Most investors don't have the resources to conduct their own independent assessment of a government or company so they turn directly to rating agencies for advice. During prosperous times when the economy is climbing, the influence of these agencies declines a bit because people tend to believe all investments or most investments are safe (and indeed, their chance for success is increased). During recessions and depressions however, while people guard their money like bees guard honey, it's a different story and the "Great Recession" of 2008 was a big one ... meaning everyone has stopped dancing to the music and is now listening very carefully to what each of the agencies have to say.
Rating agencies are far from perfect and I could easily write an entire article on how these agencies helped contribute to the "Great Recession" in the first place, but for now I am content with simply mentioning it. Yes, they were negligible with subprime mortgages by giving them higher grades than these products deserved (and thus misled investors). Now it seems, these agencies are trying desperately to restore their reputations and are constantly making adjustments to countries and institutions that were once almost always automatically given the best grades (no brainers). In the last year alone, countless governments and institutions have been downgraded by these agencies including the United States. Sometimes an agency doesn't immediately downgrade a country or region, but places them on "watch" which precisely what all the headlines about Europe are all about. The S&P warned yesterday that 15 European nations including France and Germany could possibly be downgraded in the next 90 days.
Now we come to the point about why I have a problem with what these agencies have become. You see, at a time when Europe is trying desperately to recover or to stave off the collapse of the euro, the S&P announces that it could downgrade these nations in the next 90 days. If timing is everything, then why did the S&P have to make such an ominous announcement the very week when European leaders are trying to come to a solution to the Euro-crisis? And here we have two divergent schools of thought. You are either a believer in the rating agencies, and so you feel inclined to think that precisely because European leaders are meeting this week and don't yet have a solution, that it is the duty of a rating agency to announce that they might be downgrading 15 euro countries if they don't get their act together and soon or like me, you believe the rating agencies are trying to influence certain actions by releasing information when they do, and in the form that they release it.
To bolster my argument, I would say that an American rating agency that releases a warning (which is not the same as a change in rating) on the eve of European debt crisis discussions is hoping to pressure Europeans into action. Not only are they hoping that Europeans take action, but all three rating agencies are very acutely aware of what is being discussed at these meetings (indeed, they hire some of the best analysts in the field). Does it not follow then, that these agencies might be using their influence and timing to "nudge" European nations to agree with American interests? Why do I say America's and not investors' interests? I say that because investors could profit from the collapse of the euro - there's always a way to make money but it would be very difficult for the US to profit from a collapse in its biggest export market. This information is much more helpful to US interests than it is to European interests and it remains speculative for investors at best. It is in fact detrimental to European interests since it pushes the Eurozone to brink of the abyss. Either they get something passed that appeals to the credit agencies or they can kiss their credit worthiness goodbye. See how it works?